Adele, the Grammy-winning entertainer who could seemingly do no wrong, apparently has.
On Sunday, the British singer came under fire and was accused of cultural appropriation after sharing an Instagram photo that featured her wearing a Jamaican-flag bikini top, Bantu knots in her hair, and a carnival-inspired headdress found in Afro-Caribbean cultures.
“Happy what would be Notting Hill Carnival, my beloved London,” she wrote, paying tribute to the massive community-led festival by sharing emojis of the British and Jamaican flags.
Celebrity followers including Naomi Campbell, Zoe Saldana, Tessa Thompson, Chelsea Handler, and Lisa Rinna approved her look with supportive comments.
Fans also applauded her significant weight loss and courage for posting a bikini photo. However, many others did not.
The Notting Hill Carnival celebrated Caribbean culture and began in the 1960s as a children’s street fair to ease racial tensions in the area.
It would have taken place Sunday and Monday this year but went virtual due to the COVID-19 pandemic.
“While Notting Hill Carnival is rooted in Caribbean culture, with its Windrush-generation influence remaining strongly evident, it is at the same time characteristically ‘London’ – today’s modern London,” according to the event’s website.
Performers including Jay-Z, Lil Kim, Busta Rhymes, Major Lazer, and Stefflon Don have previously taken the stage at the festival.
The “Hello” singer’s image sparked a digital culture war in comments that touched on nuanced race relations globally and how they differ from those in the U.S.
Some users harangued Adele, asked her to delete the image, and compared her to Cynthia, a character from the animated series “Rugrats,” and Rachel Dolezal, the accused former NAACP chapter president who turned out to be white.
Sports journalist Jemele Hill tweeted that “nary a person” asked for Adele’s look.
BET News host and activist Marc Lamont Hill shared the photo on his Instagram account with the caption “Why?” and sparked the debate anew there.
But more positive commentary came from several people who identified as Jamaican or African.
Users on Instagram and Twitter said they appreciated Adele’s post and the celebration behind it.
Others noted that her look wasn’t ordinary for the diverse carnival and encouraged people to learn the context.
And many observed that it was Americans who took issue with it.
“From a Jamaican… Thank you for wearing our colors, thank you for embracing our culture,” natzworldja wrote on Adele’s post.
“As a Jamaican from the U.K. I hope she doesn’t take this down. I’m so sick of Americans projecting their problems onto the rest of the world.
They need to stop!” commented ogogog333.
If 2020 couldn't get anymore bizarre, Adele is giving us Bantu knots and cultural appropriation that nobody asked for.
This officially marks all of the top white women in pop as problematic.
Hate to see it. pic.twitter.com/N9CqPqh7GX
— Ernest Owens (@MrErnestOwens) August 30, 2020
“For most Caribbean people like myself who see this, we aren’t upset.
And the reason most African American people are upset is that it is illegal for black people to wear their hair how it naturally grows or in black hairstyles in certain spaces,” _nothinlessthanreal wrote.
“…African Americans get so upset when people who never had to deal with those struggles wear certain black hairstyles.
Yes, it may not be offensive to African people or Caribbean people, but to African Americans who still get penalized for hairstyles like this, it’s upsetting.”
“Just here to let everyone know, white people telling POC how to feel about this, is in itself racist,” added death desires.
Adele has not publicly commented on the debate.
Reference: Los Angeles Time